The Health Care Gamble

Dr. Larry Wilson

The Health Care Gamble

America is considering moving toward a European-style socialized medical system. Both of the major parties’ presidential candidates, Sen. Barack Obama Sen. John McCain, are proposing significant changes to our current health care system. In this article, let us clearly explore — without mincing words — some of the dangers I see in moving toward a socialized system.

According to some, the problem is too much freedom free enterprise. The only “moral fair” solution is to mandate (read force) everyone into a universal (read socialistic) health care system. Others agree that freedom is the problem — but that there’s too little of it.

Why are costs so high?


Medical experts say costs are high because illness is expensive to treat people are living longer. However, I maintain the truth is different. You decide what you believe. Here are other costs that most experts ignore:

1. Drugs hospital care are outrageously costly. Some of this is necessary, but much is not. America Europe have a cartel-based health care system, in which drug-based medicine rules all other modalities are pushed to the side, literally.

Natural methods of care, for example, are often far less costly, but are not permitted in most hospitals. Nor are natural methods permitted in large socialist programs, such as Medicaid Medicare. Without much competition, however, drug companies are often incredibly greedy.

2. A sick population raises costs. Fully 50 percent of Americans over 40 years of age have chronic health conditions. However, the very system that would be expanded forced on all Americans is responsible for much of this disease. Why is this so?

Public health authorities such as the Food Drug Administration, Centers for Disease Control Prevention others tell us it is OK to eat sugar, as well as white flour hundreds of questionable food additives. Meanwhile, they oppose the sale of far healthier foods such as raw, certified milk cheese.

They also push the use of many questionable vaccines for children a time when they are most vulnerable to side-effects such as autism, ADHD even death.

The same authorities insist on toxic fluoride deadly chlorine in the water supply, while far safer more effective alternatives are available. All this adds greatly to the cost of health care.

3. Iatrogenic doctor-caused illness. The Journal of the American Medical Association reported that the adverse effects of drugs surgeries are the third fourth leading causes of death in America. In another report — probably more accurate — by Gary Null, Ph.D., adverse medical effects emerge as the leading cause of death disability in the U.S.

4. Malpractice. Nutritionists pay about $100 to $250 annually in malpractice insurance, but licensed drug doctors pay about 100 times this much.

Hospitals, device manufacturers others also pay high malpractice premiums. Some legal oversight is good, but the system is out of control. The enormous legal costs of medical care are passed on to you in higher prices for all drugs hospital stays.

5. Fraud other waste. In 2007, fraud in Medicare alone was estimated about $33 billion out of $426 billion, about 7.5 percent.

Instead of direct accountability to citizens, which means everyone watches his pocketbook, government systems employ armies of “health police” who chase down prosecute cheaters. Enforcement is conducted through massive amounts of paperwork. This is another huge waste of money for doctors, hospitals, labs everyone else in the health care field. The paperwork also demoralizes doctors other staff.

The amount of waste in any government health program that no one dares really investigate is staggering, far in excess of that in private health care.

6. Defensive medicine. This is the costly times, disastrous practice of prescribing extra scans, drugs even operations to satisfy licensing boards, attorneys sometimes insurers. It is standard today, especially in hospitals.

Defensive medicine is far rarer in private fee-for-service offices where the patient actually oversees the bill has a more direct relationship with the doctor staff.

7. Lobbying. Any time a government gets into business, including health care, it becomes a political hot potato. All the players want their products services covered by government programs.

Drug companies, especially, spend billions on TV ads on lobbying doctors, the FDA, FTC of course, Congress. The cost is again passed on to you, in higher prices for every medical service product.

Capitalist market failure?


See the graph on this page showing the official total of U.S. health costs over the past 67 years. Note that something dramatic happened around 1970, because health care costs exploded that time. The graph turns almost vertical. What happened was the adoption of Medicare Medicaid, America’s socialized medical programs.

In other words, the real explosion in health costs was not due to the market, but instead to its destruction. This must stop, it will just mean greater debt for our children grandchildren — until common sense returns to those we elect to office.

Understanding markets


A market means there are buyers sellers willing to bargain over prices, so that both get the best deal possible. A market also means that prices costs are transparent little is hidden from view. This is not how American health care works today.

Free market health care. During America’s first 120 years so, many healing systems competed openly on an even playing field. They included osteopathy, chiropractic, herbal medicine, drugs, homeopathy, nutrition others.

The least expensive most effective ones prevailed. Access to care was excellent for a large, growing nation, costs were kept low by competition. America had the best health in the world that time. Today we spend more, yet our health statistics are nowhere nearly as good, compared to other nations.

Few realize that the American Medical Association, AMA, was formed in 1847 because America’s free market health system worked so well. The drug doctors allopaths, as they were called, were not making enough money.

Car care as a current model. To better understand a free market, consider how cars are repaired today. Many options exist for auto care. Some people choose fancy licensed dealerships to repair their car. Others choose certified local mechanics, uncertified repair shops even do some of the work themselves.

Prices are known, plenty of competition keeps most shops fairly honest. Most importantly, a spirit of helpfulness pervades the system. As a result, even the poorest people seem to find ways to have their cars repaired adequately. Freedom of choice provides many options, the system runs smoothly with no government interference special regulations.

You may think, but it’s only a car. Yes, cars are quite complex machines to which we entrust our lives every day. But if we lose trust, we can simply change mechanics.

The uninsured “problem”

There are those who claim this is a crisis. The truth is, up to 20 percent of the uninsured qualify for government programs but have not bothered to apply. Another large group of the uninsured are illegal immigrants who cannot get insurance without a social security number. Others just prefer to spend their hard-earned money elsewhere.

In fact, there is no crisis of the uninsured. It is a false argument used to help force everyone into a very dysfunctional health care system.

Is there a right to health care?


Some people say there is a right to health care. Let us examine this carefully. Rights can be of several types.

Natural rights are those that come from the Creator. Our Declaration of Independence describes inalienable rights to life, liberty the pursuit of happiness. A right to unlimited health care services is not among them.

Entitlements are government-bestowed rights. They are more like promises from the government of certain defined goods services. For example, the right to a speedy trial by a jury of one’s peers is one of extremely few entitlements in our original Bill of Rights.

Problems with entitlements, including jury trials, are:

1. Enormous cost. In fact, our government has modified the right to a jury trial due to its cost. Few people actually get a jury trial today, even though it would be fairer.

A problem with the right to health care goods services is deciding which ones should be included. This would be debated endlessly subjected to total political manipulation. In other words, the fine print is everything in an entitlement. Otherwise, the promise is empty.

Another part of the cost is that someone must be paid to provide the goods services. This means armies of government employees are required to dole out the goods services monitor the entire process. Entitlements also cost far more than anyone can estimate, due, in large part, to the problem described below.

2. They reverse the positive incentive to take responsibility for oneself one’s family. After all, why bother caring for yourself if the government will clean up your messes? One way out of this dilemma is what I would a right to choice in health care.

Freedoms rights to choice come from the government, just like entitlements. However, they don’t cost the taxpayers a nickel. No one promises goods services with all that this entails.

Freedoms, rights to choice, are prohibitions against government interference with a particular activity behavior. Many of these are in our founding documents.

They include the right to speak freely, to worship as one chooses the right to bear arms. Dr. Benjamin Rush, a physician signer of the Declaration of Independence, suggested a right to choice in health care, but it was left out of the Bill of Rights.

This right would mean that the government may never impose a single type of health care. Citizens would always have a right to choose their health care, just as they choose their religion speech. A few in Congress have called for such a change. It would be a step in the right direction to break up the cartel-based system we currently have. It would also not require a new bureaucracy higher taxes, as entitlements always do.

It would also increase competition thus reduce our health care costs dramatically, over time.

Is “universal care” the moral solution?


Socialists say their government-run plan is the only moral solution. I disagree, here is why:

1. It is compulsory. There is nothing moral about forcing people to accept pay for drug-cartel medicine, even if one doesn’t want it won’t use it.

2. It is wasteful would be riddled with fraud. This seems immoral to me. Instead, I prefer to control my health records, not to let a large bureaucracy handle it.

3. It is based on a lie. The lie is that the government is somehow smarter than you are in figuring out your real health care needs.

The Europeans Canadians have discovered these problems with socialized medical systems. In fact, most western European Asian nations such as Japan, Great Britain, France others are looking for ways to move away from the socialistic schemes that are bankrupting their nations.

We, as individuals, must carefully examine the candidates’ positions, as certainly we do not want to establish a new, large entitlement program that will likely further rob us of our money, our freedom what is left of our health as a nation. For more information about each candidate’s proposed health care plan, see their Web sites.

References


1. A good source of official government information about health care.

2. Goodman, J.C. Musgrave, G.L., Patient Power: Solving America’s Health Care Crisis, Cato Institute, Washington, DC, 1992.

3. Health, US, 2006. Table 120, U.S. Department of Health Human Services, Centers For Disease Control Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics, Hyattsville, MD, 2006.

4. Hornberger, J. Ebeling, R., editors, The Dangers of Socialized Medicine, Future of Freedom Foundation, Fairfax, VA, 1994.

5. Ruwart, M.J., Healing Our World, SunStar Press, Kalamazoo, MI, 1993.

6. Skousen, W.C., The Five Thousand Year Leap, The National Center for Constitutional Studies, Washington, DC, 1981.

7. Wasley, T., What Has Government Done to Our Health Care, Cato Institute, Washington, DC, 1992.

8. Wiley, H., The History of a Crime Against the Food Law: The Story of the National Food Drugs Law Intended to Protect the Health of the People, Perverted to Protect Adulteration of Foods Drugs, Harvey Wiley, Washington, DC, 1929, 1955. Wiley was the first director (1906-12) of the Bureau of Chemistry, later renamed the Food Drug Administration.

Dr. Lawrence Wilson has a medical degree has been in the health field for more than 25 years. His books include Nutritional Balancing Hair Mineral Analysis, Legal Guidelines for Unlicensed Practitioners, Healing Ourselves Manual of Sauna Therapy and The Real Self. He also co-authored Toxic Metals in Human Health Disease contributed to The Dangers of Socialized Medicine. or.

Reprinted from AzNetNews, Volume 27, Number 5, October/November 2008.

Found this helpful? Share it with someone who needs it.